Following his death in 1883, a subscription fund was opened for a memorial to commemorate his public service and J. Milo Griffith received the commission for £1,000 in 1884. The statue evoked strong emotions in Cardiff with the Western Mail publishing a mock epitaph written by political rivals. This led to an assault on the paper's editor by Batchelor's sons. In January 1887 the council was presented with a petition signed by 1200 people requesting the removal of the statue as it was occupying valuable ground and because he was a man 'whose memory is associated with the politics of a particular party'. The petition was rejected. Also in January 1887 the statue was daubed with paint and coal tar. The statue remained in situ and became a popular venue for open-air political meetings.
The Cardiff Free Library opened in June 1896 as the cover of the programme of the proceedings indicates. [535]